Conference Beyond Binaries: Intersex Body Politics in Premodern Islamic Legal, Medical, and Literary Discourses

International Conference

Beyond Binaries: Intersex Body Politics in Premodern Islamic Legal, Medical, and Literary Discourses

Utrecht University, Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies

Sweelinckzaal (Drift 21, room 0.05)

Wednesday 26 June 2024

While, on the one hand, numerous studies have currently focused on the history of Islamic doctrines and cultural traditions concerning gender and sexuality, such as effeminacy, transgenderism, and homosexuality, the questions regarding intersex topics in Islam and Muslim culture, despite having great visibility in terms of how they are publicly debated and invoked in polemical contexts, have hardly been tackled comprehensively by scholars of Islam. On the other hand, presently, traditional Muslim scholars and public preachers often advocate for Islam as intolerant of trans-genderism or non-binary sex/gender divisions (see, for example, Assim al Hakeem: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQ0DE7tI7No; Yasir Qadhi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iCsUXGz1_6I; Amer, Jamil: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oWF-b_rXwpU). Not surprisingly, this dominant approach has reinforced orientalist narratives insisting that the male-female binary conception of humanity in Islamic teaching is a monolithic rigid code without room for discussion and historical developments. For example, Paula Sanders, in “Gendering the Ungendered Body,” argued for the following two notions: (1) premodern Islamic legal and medical texts demand sex and gender dimorphism that strictly define males and females as true opposites; (2) medieval Muslim jurists could not tolerate intersex ambiguity and imposed a gender on such (“unsexed-ungendered”) bodies to protect against social disorder and preserve male-dominated sexual hierarchy (Sanders 1991). Astonishingly, she drew such a broad conclusion primarily based on an examination of four mainly eleventh-century legal manuals, dominantly Kitāb al-mabsūṭ of the Ḥanafī jurist Muḥammad Ibn Aḥmad al-Sarakhsī (d. 1090). Despite the limitation of Sanders’s study, her thesis has been championed by various scholars of Islamic, Middle Eastern, and gender studies in the last three decades.

By contrast, Muslim discourses on sex or gender are oftentimes surprisingly dynamic. Therefore, some scholars have challenged Sanders’s position and upheld that the recognition of the intersex category as a non-binary possibility is particularly significant as classical Muslim jurists and physicians acknowledged the complex identification of such individuals, even when assigning them a specific legal sex/gender (Gesink 2018, Alipour 2017, Geissinger 2012). Moreover, contemporary grassroots-level activists and Muslim reformist scholars lobby for a more accepting attitude, referring to Islam’s inbuilt tolerance of both biological sex fluidity and non-binary conceptions of gender.

This conference thus offers a scholarly assessment of the premodern Muslim medical practice, Islamic law, and Persian and Arabic literary trajectories demarcating the space between the two poles of acceptance and rejection of the third sex and/or gender in premodern Muslim discourses. Its enquiry thus relates to the sex and/or gender identity(ies) of intersex individuals in Islamic legal, medical, and literary debates, including:

• What are the discursive spaces on intersex topics in Islamic legal, medical, and/or literary debates?
• How did Muslim premodern medical experts perceive intersex bodies and behavioural characteristics?
• How have intersex topics shaped Muslim legal and/or medical discourses concerning binary/non-binary debates?
• How were intersex people illustrated in premodern Persian and Arabic literature in terms of their behavioural and biological characteristics?
• What was the reception of intersex people in premodern Muslim culture?
• What is the correlation between intersex (khunthā) and effeminate (mukhannath) in premodern Muslim vernacular culture as depicted by Persian and/or Arabic poetry and prose?

Programme

09.30 Welcome and opening Mehrdad Alipour

Session One: Chair Mehrdad Alipour

09.45   Loren Schechter (Rush University)

               Variations in Sex Traits and Surgery: Consensus and Controversy

10.15   Mir Abe Marinus (NNID, Netherlands’ organisation for sex diversity)

               Intersex in the Dutch law – slow wheels turning in a heteronormative system

10.45   Susannah Cornwall (University of Exeter)

Biblical and Rabbinic Accounts of Intersex Variations

11.15   Coffee break

Session Two: Chair Ash Geissinger

 11.45   Indira Falk Gesink (Baldwin Wallace University, Keynote)

               Islamic Perspectives on Intersex and Implications for Treatment

13.00   Lunch break

Session Three: Chair Asghar Seyed-Gohrab

14.30   Ash Geissinger (Carleton University)

Notes on gender as a spectrum in Sunni Hadith literature

15.00   Ari Schriber (Utrecht University)

         Intersex as Evidentiary Problem: Locating the Khunthā in Post Classical Mālikī Law

15.30   Saqer A. Almarri (New York University Abu Dhabi)

Shurayh, Ali, and the Khuntha: Gender and Narrative Fluidity
16.00   Coffee break

Session Four: Chair Susannah Cornwall

 16.30   Asghar seyed-Gohrab (Utrecht University)

Intersex Characters (mukhannath and khunthā) in Classical Persian Poetry

17.00   Arash Ghajarjazi (Utrecht University)

Sexual Indeterminacy in Safavid Literary Biographies

17.30   Mehrdad Alipour (Utrecht University)

               Body Politics in Premodern Islamic-Persian Medical Discourse

18.00   Closing Remarks

This conference is part of the Veni Grant “Beyond Binaries: Intersex in Islamic Legal Tradition” awarded to Dr. Mehrdad Alipour by the Dutch Research Council (NWO). Please contact Mehrdad for more information: m.alipoorkalaei@uu.nl